Evy Mages itibaren San Giacomo TE, Italy

_vy_ages

12/22/2024

Kitap için kullanıcı verileri, yorumlar ve öneriler

Evy Mages Kitabın yeniden yazılması (10)

2018-04-23 17:40

Kuşku TrendKitaplar Kütüphanesi

Tarafından yazılmış kitap Tarafından: Martı Yayınları

They were handing a free book out at the gate to a rooftop films screening. Why? A scene was set at rooftop films, I was told. Or at least a scene on a rooftop alluded to rooftop films. Turns out it was by Jim Munroe, a past editor of Adbusters. The back blurb was awful, something about an occultist roommate turning into a touring performance act. It got buried in a pile. To be dug out semi-randomly. I'd assumed that this would be a continuation of my genre-fiction-only plan, still underway despite some Borges stories, but rather than than being the horror novel I was expecting given the ostensible subject of demonology, it's much more what I should have expected from an editor of Adbusters: thoughts on pop-culture, sub-culture, and the negotiation of life and art while getting older. Despite being (admittedly) basically the target reader of a book so rife with cultural references, at first I found the culturally relevant detail somewhat distracting. More on this below. Also, the book unfolds in blog format, which is both kitschy in that same "culturally relevant" way and entirely unconvincing in that narrator Kate blogs exactly as if she were writing a novel, complete with implausibly detailed (and often rather uninteresting) banter and a completely leaden ear to the more conversational idiosyncracies of most blogging. The only times it's obvious the story is a blog are in the segues, and in the rare but amusing sequences where Kate gets bored and lets her entries trail off into fiction and lies. (Okay, so Munroe wins back some "formatting gimmick" points, for also releasing the book free online as an actual blog. I gotta admit that his money is largely where his mouth is, and he is no stranger to alternative and easily distributable media formats.) Most of that was written in annoyance halfway through the book, but plotwise, it does pick up somewhat in the second half when the the story condenses into a road trip. It's still mostly a vehicle for cultural observation, but somehow I ended up endeared to the key characters anyway, for no easily identifiable reason. Getting back to that cultural observation: as I said, I'm about as close to a target audience for all the references as could be hoped for, and they irked me a bit. Why? Well, some of it was superfluous: do we need a page long Shaolin Soccer digression, a full explanation of slash fanfic*, and frequent analogies using the likes of China Mieville, Cat Power, and Guided By Voices? Those first two especially: they're a bit too didactic, a bit too "let me introduce you to a cultural artifact that may interest you." Maybe it's partly that the book was published in 2004 and up-to-the-minute references date extremely quickly. The broader references to art/music life and its signifiers seems a little more timeless, of course. I wonder how this could be done well. Time actually helps, perhaps once you move past the period where everything is a little too late to be new. Pynchon (apparently now the author that I invariably end up referencing in reviews and I am sorry for that) is full of cultural references of whatever era he's dealing with, but they're delightful. I think distance also helps as far as tone goes: there is less of a sense of imparting knowledge after a certain point, and references become background detail. For more currently set books, though, I think the dangers can be avoided by cutting the specifics and keeping cultural reference to its broader shapes and senses. I suspect Great Jones Street fared just fine in its own time, and whatever its other failings, the feeling of a (nonspecific) band on the cusp of its potential was what You Don't Love Me Yet actually did pull off most effectively. This deserves more thought, especially since it's the sort of pitfall I'm likely to blunder into if I do start writing my own fiction again, at some point. Thoughts? *On the other hand, how could I really fault a book for referencing Draco/Harry slash fic, which I think was the first instance of the peculiar popular phenomenon I ran into as well.

Okuyucu Evy Mages itibaren San Giacomo TE, Italy

Kullanıcı, bu kitapları portalın yayın kurulu olan 2017-2018'de en ilginç olarak değerlendirdi "TrendKitaplar Kütüphanesi" Tüm okuyucuların bu literatürü tanımalarını tavsiye eder.