Yönergeleri Dinleyelim - Halime Tosun ücretsiz kitap indir

R Cantuario cantuario_9ada — Curious, sad and lovely too, I'm not sure how to feel about this book. The story of a young girl, at 9, 12, 17 and older, with a particular gift, and her peculiar family. You feel the loneliness of Rose, and her Mom, Dad and brother, and so wish that they could talk to each other or someone in their lives. Wow, this book really speaks to the inherent isolation of all people, and in that sense, is not fun to read. And yet, I did love the book, I'm just not sure why.

Lorrie Wu happylorrie — Gateway winner 2009-2010. Definitely for high school/8th grade readers. A good story, but I found it a bit flat. I didn't find Hannah's character as believable as it could have been, and I felt like the smaller pieces linking the tape sessions together were a little forced and weak. I am sure this book is ground-breaking because there isn't a lot like it out there, but I just am not convinced as to the authenticity of the character's voices or the story itself. The plot isn't very realistic, but maybe that's not a flaw...maybe it's not supposed to be. If the book's purpose is to stir up emotion and cause kids to sit up and take notice of others, then it's successful. But the content itself has little to do with actual suicides and is a far cry from real life and the actual behaviors of truly depressed people. The whole idea of this girl documenting things doesn't really ring true...I think that anyone committing suicide is far past putting forth effort to plan such an elaborate departure. What is realistic is the notion that people go through life without really taking the feelings of others into consideration. The book probably appeals to the high school set because it's a sad one, as sad books typically garner a lot of attention. It's OK, but it's not as authentic as I'd like it to be.